
Should I start J.J. McCarthy or Tyler Shough? (Standard Week 18 2026)
THE FF CALL
Slight lean: Tyler Shough
Week 18 ยท Standard
Tyler Shough has the higher current FF forecast: 15.8 FP versus 15.6 FP. The 0.2-point gap is small; saved experimental forecasts provide context, not a separate override.
Tyler Shough ยท Injury report dated ยท Starter role checked
J.J. McCarthy ยท Injury report dated ยท Starter role checked
- Tyler Shough: 14.8 FP recent scoring average.
- Tyler Shough: 3.75% matchup reduction against TB.
Forecast updated ยท Standard



Tyler Shough
QB ยท NOStats & schedule โบJ.J. McCarthy
- Recent scoring average: 12.2 FP.
- Last 2 recorded games: 10.5 pass attempts per game.
Tyler Shough
- Recent scoring average: 14.8 FP.
- The TB defensive matchup changes the FF estimate down 3.75%.
- Last 3 recorded games: 34.3 pass attempts per game.
J.J. McCarthy
- FF projection
- 15.6 FP -0.9vs ESPN
- ESPN
- 16.5 FP
- Sleeper
- 13.5 FP
- FantasyPros
- 15.7 FP
- Boosted Trees
- 18.6 FP
- Experimental ยท saved Oct 27, 12:03 AM ET
J.J. McCarthy faces PHI in Week 18. Recent scoring average: 12.2 fantasy points.
Tyler Shough
- FF projection
- 15.8 FP +2.3vs ESPN
- ESPN
- 13.5 FP
- Sleeper
- 14.2 FP
- FantasyPros
- 18.5 FP
- Boosted Trees
- 16.2 FP
- Experimental ยท saved Oct 27, 12:03 AM ET
Tyler Shough faces TB in Week 18. Recent scoring average: 14.8 fantasy points. The position-specific defensive matchup adjusts the forecast down 3.75%.
Your next decision
Scoring & lineup notes
FORTIFIED RANKINGS ยท
QB. The bigger picture.
Ranked by FF expected points. Displayed ties favor the higher FF-minus-ESPN margin. Medians and ranges add context.
- 1
Josh AllenQB ยท BUF vs NYJSun 12:00 AM ETRange unavailableMean 24.8Range unavailableMedian unavailableESPN 25.2Sleeper 24.6FantasyPros 23.624.8Expected FP - 2
Brock PurdyQB ยท SF vs ARISun 12:00 AM ETRange unavailableMean 24.4Range unavailableMedian unavailableESPN 20.6Sleeper 24.8FantasyPros 22.624.4Expected FP - 3
Jayden DanielsQB ยท WAS vs DALSun 12:00 AM ETRange unavailableMean 24.3Range unavailableMedian unavailableESPN 21.9Sleeper 21.3FantasyPros 22.024.3Expected FP
How the forecast and ranges work
FF uses position-specific provider weights, rescored CBS and FFToday stats, and the existing bounded form, defense and metric adjustments. Saved Boosted Trees and Workload have bounded model influence when available. Monte Carlo supplies the distribution; it does not get a duplicate mean vote.
Every player is ranked by the FF expected score (mean), whether or not a simulation distribution is available. Equal displayed scores use the higher FF-minus-ESPN margin when both ESPN forecasts are known, then unrounded FF, a comparable FantasyPros/Sleeper estimate, and stable identity order if still level. This tiebreaker is not a measured probability of beating ESPN. The median marker is additional information and never changes the order. Missing or availability-conditional ranges do not switch the ranking statistic. The window shows the experimental middle 80% (P10โP90), rather than the difference between two model means. Its observed coverage under this new version is still collecting. Availability-conditional distributions are labeled and are not shifted to a different center.
Missing sources and incompatible scoring are excluded. Bye and confirmed unavailable players remain excluded. ESPN, Sleeper and FantasyPros are the benchmark markers. The common scale covers the displayed outcome windows and available benchmarks.
More Week 18 decisions
Tyler Shough15.8projected FP
Kirk Cousins18.2projected FP
Tyler Shough15.8projected FP
Bo Nix15.7projected FP
Tyler Shough15.8projected FP
Aaron Rodgers15.9projected FP
Tyler Shough15.8projected FP
Geno Smith15.6projected FP
Josh Allen24.8projected FP
Brock Purdy24.4projected FP
Brock Purdy24.4projected FP
Jayden Daniels24.3projected FP
Jayden Daniels24.3projected FP
Jordan Love23.4projected FP
Jordan Love23.4projected FP
Joe Burrow22.4projected FP
Joe Burrow22.4projected FP
Drake Maye22.2projected FP
Drake Maye22.2projected FP
C.J. Stroud22.1projected FP