FORTIFIED FANTASY
← All Week 12 comparisons

2026 · Week 12 · Standard

Should I start Caleb Williams or Josh Allen in Week 12 (2026)?

The projection call

A close call. Slight lean: Josh Allen

Josh Allen projects for 22.0 points in standard scoring, 0.5 more than Caleb Williams. The gap is small; late injury news or your league’s scoring can change the choice.

QB · CHI

Caleb Williams

21.5 projected FP

Standard · FantasyPros weekly projection

vs DET

Kickoff ·

QB · BUF

Josh Allen

22.0 projected FP

Standard · FantasyPros weekly projection

vs KC

Kickoff ·

Saved data; refresh temporarily unavailable. . Projected points are not actual results.

Your lineup. Your league’s rules.

Make the call with your whole team.

Connect ESPN for matchup research, league scoring, waivers, and your game-flow timeline.

Connect my ESPN teams ↗

Before you lock it in

Less than one projected point separates these players. Treat this as a close decision rather than a confident bench call. Confirm active status, kickoff time and your league’s scoring. This page does not include verified late injury or weather updates.

What changes in PPR, half-PPR and standard?

PPR awards one point per reception; half-PPR awards 0.5; standard awards no reception point. Use the scoring buttons above to compare the same players under each preset. Passing TDs, bonuses and other custom rules may differ in your league.

More Week 12 decisions

QB · Week 12Caleb Williams or Trevor Lawrence?21.5 vs 20.7 projected · Compare the matchup ↗QB · Week 12Trevor Lawrence or Jared Goff?20.7 vs 20.4 projected · Compare the matchup ↗QB · Week 12Jared Goff or Patrick Mahomes II?20.4 vs 19.6 projected · Compare the matchup ↗QB · Week 12Patrick Mahomes II or Bryce Young?19.6 vs 19.5 projected · Compare the matchup ↗QB · Week 12Bryce Young or Jayden Daniels?19.5 vs 19.2 projected · Compare the matchup ↗QB · Week 12Jayden Daniels or Tyler Shough?19.2 vs 18.9 projected · Compare the matchup ↗